Despite being hyped up as one of the best One-piece films, I could only say that Film z was just above average. I always go into movies with tempered expectations, as I have yet to see one that was truly amazing. However, I let my and get ahead itself when I was expecting the best One-Piece movie. I wouldn’t say it was the best movie, as Film Gold was slightly better, and Stampede was even better, but it was a pretty decent film that wasn’t bad as so much it was disappointing. Probably the best thing Film Z has going for it is its organicand great plot for a movie. Starting with an incredible action scene starring Z, Kizaru, and thousands of CG marines engaged in an all-out battle, your first thought is wow, closely followed by, this is our antagonist? Z proceeds to blow up a volcano and use that to escape the island, where he is picked up by the Staw Hats (who found him floating in the sea, after presumably a few days) and heal him, unaware of what he did. When he wakes up, they even build up Z as a good person; overall, as he has this conversation with Luffy about freedom and good people before Luffy lets it spill that they are pirates. Z switches immediately and beats up all the Straw Hats in rage before calling his fleet to bombard the Thousand Sunny and leave them dead. And while all of this is happening, they turn Nami, Robin, and brook into children, Franky performing a coup de burst last second and saving the crew from annihilation. We then find out that his name is Z, a character who is rupturing three seismic points that would trigger an explosion that would destroy the whole of the New-World, and hates pirates and marines. And then, the show hits the 20 minute mark. It felt like One Piece with the fast-moving plot, interesting buildup, and multiple pieces moving plat the same time. In 20 minutes, it set up a reason why the Navy was involved, a motive for the Straw Hats, and a World threat, and an Interesting Antagonist, amazingly done for such a low budget movie (more on that later).
Like my other One Piece reviews, I always mention the worldbuilding in either its glory or lack thereof, and in this movie, I could only say that it was disappointing. Not to say that the worldbuilding was bad, but it was the average movie setting you would expect. It did nothing to strengthen or build the world (something that a movie doesn’t need to do, but one I expect from One Piece movies), and the only pieces were just plot convenience, as the seismic points were never mentioned in the canon of the story. The islands they went to weren’t super inspired either, just regular towns, filled with mostly regular inventions, no transponder snails, or other One-Piece inventions present. However, it really was the people involved rather than the physical worldbuilding that was present in this movie. Right out of the blue, we meet Aokiji and see that he lost a leg and arm. The marines are more present in the film as they have a personal connection to the villain that doesn’t boil down too, “He big bad. Let’s embarrass ourselves and the Navy.” There was some nice information on the Navy (actually cannon) in the backstory of Z, and we had screen time for some marines that we hadn’t seen In awhile. While Oda did not confirm the movie as cannon, it was a nice way of spinning worldbuilding and creating some amazing bonds, the backstory with Z being One Piece of cannon. (Spoilers in the next paragraph.)
Z, or later revealed to be Zephyr, was a decent antagonist but nowhere near the movie's saving grace. His backstory boils down to him being a noble person and joining the Marines, but after seeing one of the warlords kill his wife and be let off the hook, he quit the marines and formed his own justice unit. However, this was not before becoming an admiral and training most of the Admirals, Vice Admirals, and captains of the Marines. Now I guess the biggest problem with his character arc was that it wasn’t given adequate time to develop in a believable way. And I understand that it was a movie, but there are plenty of other movies that can develop it in a perfectly acceptable way. It just felt rushed. When he and the Straw Hats first interact, we do see that he is a good person and believes in absolute justice, turning on the Straw Hats in seconds when he finds out who they are. And throughout the movie, we are peppered with hints and bonds he has with marines, making him out to be a good antagonist, the buildup of his character, and his loyal subordinates making perfect sense. However, his ending was completely rushed and messed up the things he had going for him. Despite being all about absolute justice, he gets talk no jutsu’d by Luffy literally fighting for selfish reasons. He fights with Luffy for a bit, and after realizing and accepting way too fast that Luffy is a good pirate, he immediately stops fighting and chooses to sacrifice himself. The movie literally speeds through the last and most important part of his character arc, ignoring all the buildup before. I understand that he wanted to be beaten as he knew he was wrong, and I understood why he would react that way after fighting Luffy, but there needed to be more time from him literally hating all pirates as the spawn of the devil to instantly thinking that they are all fine, and even some worth DYING for. His lackeys were also weird. The Ninja didn’t even have a personality, failing the one thing that each side villain should at least have, but he was honestly better than the other lackey, who was a complete waste of potential. One, she had a cool devil fruit that is a copy of Jewelry Bonne’s and was only used once (in a masterful way). Second, she was a swordswoman, allowing her to fight Zoro in the most anticlimactic fight ever. While the Ninja had no personality, the number of times foreshadowed that something was “holding her back” or “not allowing her to fight at full power” was ridiculous, as she was beaten without it even being revealed. We never learned what her burden was, and it was literally such a big movie plot point. But enough of my rant.
The other characters were fine in the movie providing the interactions we needed and enjoyed, especially the Marines. For the majority of the movies, the Marines are done dirty, acting dumber than and shooting with less accuracy than the Stormtroopers in Star Wars. But with the Marines an Integral part of Z’s past and storyline in the movie, they represented the Marines that they were. Instead of just being all-powerful, Kizaru felt more of a character in his fights and conversations with Z. Although Aokiji has had a lot of development, we get more from him, as he also has some conversations with the marines. And playing their role like in all the movies, Garp and Sengoku hype up the main villain, this time with an actual personal connection that feels real, and not just talking about them to make the villain out to be powerful. The side characters were fine in One Piece standards, and quite good characters standalone, each affecting the story in their own way. However, if there was one thing to complain about and say was the worst part of the movie, it would be the animation. It was fine for the most part, providing some nice fight scenes and showcasing each different Haki. Nami looked even more amazing than usual, and the outfits the Straw hats had in the final sequence were quite inspired and cool. They even managed to give good choreography to the giant steel arm that Zephyr had, hard as that might be. But the sheer amount of CG in the movie was terrible. With over half the marines involved made of CG, it made the movie feel cheap and low production, as 2dcharacters would sometimes clash with 3d characters. However, that wasn’t the worst part, only one small part of the issue. The main issue, which many movies have been doing recently, is mixing CG when it isn’t even needed. During fights and once or twice normally, they did this, causing the characters to switchback and forth from 2d to 3d 3 times within 10 seconds. It makes the dimensions of the show feel off and ruins the fights as they blatantly change from animation to CG and pretend that it wasn’t obvious. It doesn’t seem like good CG, as they never portray it at the front of the scene, always hidden or in faraway shots. The CG kept showing up in the worst parts possible and ruined the so highly praised fights, and it confuses me when people say that the animation of the movie was amazing. It was probably the movie's biggest downfall, despite having solid scenes and animation for the rest of the movie.
Overall, Film Z is an overhyped One-Piece Film that suffers from a bad ending, small worldbuilding, and a low budget. Comparing it to regular One Piece, I would rate it below every single arc excluding Syrup village, as Syrup village didn’t have the villain that Film Z did. And not to say that the film was bad, but that it isn’t the amazing film it’s been hyped up to be, ranking only as a “good” movie. I would recommend you watch it but come in with tempered expectations.
Story 7/10
Art 5/10
Sound 7/10
Character 6/10
Enjoyment 6/10
Overall 6/10