Manaphy: The Movie is the fourth and last film in the Pokemon Advance series. While the film series continued onward with annual releases under a slightly different name, this was the last we saw of May and Max. The first Advance film gave Max some focus, but both characters were generally reduced to supporting roles. Luckily for May, Pokémon Ranger and the Prince of the Sea: Manaphy decided to focus on her. And lucky indeed she is, because the fourth Advance film is the only of the four I can consider good without reservations. While the slapstick antics of the titular ranger, Jack, did initially turnme off the film, they're used sparingly. Phantom and his pirate crew border on the ridiculous as well, but just like Jack, they're used in moderation and mostly in good taste. Mostly.
One of the major things that make this film stand out from most Pokemon sequels are interesting side characters. The family Ash and company come in contact with this time aren't exceeding strange or special. They feel like normal people and as normal people, they have small quirks which the film uses to flesh them out as unique and interesting - the ways they dress, talk, walk and think. The film succeeds at painting the relationships of the supporting cast as real and fine dialogue makes them interesting enough to follow. Their distinct "house" is given its own visual identity, as well. Because of this, film successfuly indulges into 40 minutes of set up and casual character building.
Handled wrongly, Manaphy herself could have ended up as an annoying baby and a catalyst for many frustrating moments. This doesn't happen. In the film, Manaphy bonds with May, and although May isn't interesting here as she is in the fourth season of the regular Pokemon show, she can take the spotlight just fine.
While the film is plot driven, a large chunk of the middle half is spent on a journey. Here the focus is on the relationship between May and Manaphy and I'm happy to say - this relationship makes the film shine. And it's accompanied by some quite sophisticated dialogue for a Pokemon film, or at the very least for a later Pokemon film. These scenes are the best that this film has to offer.
Some other standout moments are Manaphy's search for May's scarf and the exchange between Jack and Ash with May joining in later. On a less positive note, the migrant family of circus entertainers has enough money for top tier sea equipment, boats and submarines. In the film they proceed to destroy these vehicles and you can't stop and wonder - how rich do they have to be not to even mention the loss?
The last third of this film, features a fantastic sea temple and while I've had my rants regarding vague magic in Pokemon before, this one's not a thorn in my side. "A legendary did it" is not the best possible explanation, but considering how the temple was used in the film, it gets a pass.
In the last act, the film serves us a nice surprise - Ash acting heroic. There's some neat action and Ash, who usually spouts exposition while his pokemon do all the work, plunges right into the action and saves the day. While the ending could certianly do with some more May, Ash makes it worthwile.
All in all, while the whole deal with nonsensical yellow powers at the end does lower the score, the vast majority of the film is nested in the fine-to-pretty-good area. Manaphy and May were an enjoyable pair and the plot was solid, even if a bit barebones. I think that the film could've benefited from the apearance of Phione, but that's a nitpick.